PCCPATIENT CLARITY CLINIC

← All free guides

Free guide

DNACPR decisions: what they mean and your rights

Written by Sohail Hussain, Physician Associate · Last reviewed 10 November 2026 · 5 minute read

What a DNACPR decision is, what it isn’t, and what the law says about your right to be involved.

DNACPR

Only about CPR

All other care and treatment carries on.

You should be involved

The law expects the patient, or family, to be consulted.

You can ask questions

Including why, and whether it will be reviewed.

What is a DNACPR decision?

The medical explanation

A recorded decision not to attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation (chest compressions, defibrillation and assisted breathing) if the heart or breathing stops.

The everyday explanation

If your relative’s heart stops, the team will not try to restart it.

What this means for you

It is usually made because CPR would not work or would do more harm than good. Ask which applies.

What carries on, and what doesn’t

Carries on as normalAntibiotics and medicinesFluidsOxygenPain and symptom reliefFood and drinkNursing care and comfort Not attempted if the heart stopsChest compressionsDefibrillator shocksAssisted breathing for arrest

A DNACPR decision is not a decision to stop caring, and it should be reviewed if things change.

What the law says

Senior clinicianconsiders CPR Can the patient decide for themselves? Yes No Discuss withthe patientThey can refuseCPR Consult family,carers or attorneyDecide in theirbest interests Decision recordedand explained to you Reviewed ifthings change

Tap a heading to read more. This covers England and Wales.

Who makes the decision?

CPR is a medical treatment, so the decision is made by the senior clinician responsible for care. National guidance from the BMA, Resuscitation Council UK and Royal College of Nursing says patients and families cannot insist on CPR that the team believes will not work.

When CPR might work but could cause more harm than good, the person’s own wishes carry great weight, and they should be at the centre of that decision.

The right to be involved

In Tracey v Cambridge University Hospitals (Court of Appeal, 2014), the court ruled that patients should be involved before a DNACPR decision is made, unless there is a convincing reason not to. Failing to do so breached the right to respect for private life under Article 8 of the Human Rights Act.

A doctor feeling the conversation would be upsetting is not, on its own, a good enough reason to leave the patient out.

If your relative cannot decide for themselves

In Winspear v City Hospitals Sunderland (High Court, 2015), the court ruled that when a patient lacks capacity, the team must consult family or carers before the decision is made, where it is practicable and appropriate. This comes from section 4 of the Mental Capacity Act 2005.

Being consulted means your views and knowledge of your relative must be taken into account. It does not give the family a veto.

Refusing CPR in advance

An adult with capacity can refuse CPR now, or in advance with an Advance Decision to Refuse Treatment. To be legally binding for CPR, it must be in writing, signed, witnessed, and state that it applies “even if life is at risk”.

If it is valid and applies to the situation, clinicians must follow it.

Lasting Power of Attorney

A health and welfare attorney can refuse CPR on the person’s behalf only if the LPA gives them authority over life-sustaining treatment. Like anyone else, an attorney cannot insist on CPR that the team believes will not work.

Fairness and discrimination

Each decision must be about the individual. It should never be made because of age, disability or a diagnosis alone, and never applied to whole groups of people. Blanket decisions can breach the Human Rights Act and the Equality Act 2010.

If you disagree

Start at step 1. Most concerns are settled early. 1Speak to the senior doctor2Ask what it is based on3Ask about a second opinion4PALS or a complaint5Take legal advice

The team is not always obliged to arrange a second opinion, but many will. Every hospital has a PALS team who can help. For serious disputes, the Court of Protection can decide in some cases.

Questions you could ask

  • Why has this decision been made?
  • Is it because CPR wouldn’t work, or because of the harm it could cause?
  • What treatment will still be given?
  • Has my relative’s view, or ours, been taken into account?
  • When will it be reviewed?

Need help with a DNACPR conversation?

We can explain what it means for your relative and help you prepare. The first 15-minute call is free.

Book your free call

Sources and further reading

This guide is general information about the law in England and Wales. It is not legal or medical advice about any individual. Always discuss your relative’s situation with the team caring for them, and take legal advice for a specific dispute.